Ralf Bendrath, Research Fellow, University of Bremen
The panellist presented security as a warranty for the future from a scientific perspective since he has security policies background then he reminded that total security cannot be reached. “Actual security discussions are linked to the famous national security but maybe in future IGF meetings we may discuss other issues related to cyber wars for example”. “There is between bad and good the issue of well intended actions like hacking tools which are used by administrators to monitor their networks”.
Huang Chengqing, Secretary-General, Internet Society of China, Beijing
Internet security should be included in the social agenda of governments. Two levels are suggested to study the issues of internet governance at an upper level and then a lower level including Private Sector and Civil Society to discuss the technical aspects with the help of UN and ITU which should have a bigger role in this process. “Fresh” statistics show that Spam coming from China is decreasing compared to other countries. However other problems like phishing or cyber attacks increased. Information security issues are due to the change from technical challenges to income reasons to hackers.
Marco Gercke, Professor of Criminal Law, University of Cologne
Legal standards Important and we can use for the moment what we have already. People in the room now do not share the same tools but share the same technical standards which works. Law enforcement agencies have to cooperate. We have only one international convention concerning cyber crime by the Council of Europe and signed only by 43 countries mainly developed already. No success to reach more developing countries even if the increase rate in information technology users is higher than the one in developed countries. We need more people involved in the discussion and to join the group in order to make progress in the field especially with the help of the ITU which is already organizing meetings in the area.
Lamia Chaffai, Director, Tunisia Internet Agency, Tunisia
Tunisia is trying to take profit from the electronic economy. However, this is not easy at the regional level especially with the fact that our country is the only with an alert centre to avoid being used as a relay for bigger attacks against other countries. This has to be improved at the regional level. Tunisia is trying to help other African countries to use more e-commerce by organizing regional events to enhance the security awareness.
Cristine Hoepers, Leader, Brazilian CERT
Policy, legislation and technical solutions are the main pillars of security issues.
The centre of response is dealing with day to day issues and undertaking studies in the field. The studies show that some major problems have more than 20 years old. We need to think how to introduce security awareness in the minds of future engineers and explain it as a hole process not only as a technical aspect. With the cooperation required between all the actors we need also to work on preparing the next generation to reduce future problems.
Zahid Jamil, Senior Partner, Jamil & Jamil Barristers-at-Law
The Pakistani government was surprised by the use of IT in terrorism act before having the right law against such activities. The one thing we need to find is the harmonious definition of cyber crimes and the convention of the council of Europe is the only initiative for that. It’s not the mandate of the ITU to regulate the internet.